Give feedback that strengthens, not strains, relationships
By Emily Halloran | 4-minute read
Reviewing other people’s writing is a key skill for managers and other senior staff. But executives and team leaders tell us it’s one of the most challenging parts of people management. So, how do you give feedback that strengthens rather than strains your relationship with the writer?
Actually review the document (don’t rewrite it)
Writers tend to resent being elbowed out of the way. The first time it happens, they could interpret it as you helping them out of a sticky situation. But if it keeps happening, writers may think you doubt their skills, which could damage your relationship as trust is key to a good working relationship.
If your first instinct is to rewrite, you may need to develop your diagnostic skills, so you can explain exactly what you want the writer to do and why.
Explain your suggestions
Even very good reviewers can find it hard to articulate what they want writers to do, let alone why. But without a rationale, convincing a writer to change can be nearly impossible. And if things don’t change, you risk giving the same feedback every time, which is frustrating for everyone involved.
Consider explaining how your suggestion benefits the reader – after all, that’s who we’re writing for. For example, ‘Please delete your key findings and their implications from the end of each section. Your current approach has this information at the start and end of each section. Time-poor readers will benefit from a shorter report that sequences information in descending order of priority. Let’s prioritise your key findings and their implications.’
Look for patterns, tailor feedback and avoid judgements
Try turning specific grievances into a general lesson. Look for patterns. Is there a persistent issue that pops up in several places? If you can identify a general pattern rather than nitpick over every issue, your feedback can be shorter and more productive. Your writer will feel like you’re helping them develop their skills rather than tearing down every one of their carefully crafted sentences.
Obviously, you should tailor your feedback based on:
- the writer’s experience level
- the time you have available
- your relationship with them.
If they’re a seasoned writer with robust self-esteem, you can afford to be more direct. But if the writer is new or you sense their confidence is fragile, you’ll need to explain your expectations more carefully. Showing your writer you know them and understand their needs will build trust between you and strengthen your relationship.
Research shows that reviewers ‘overestimate the negative consequences of providing negative feedback, leading them to provide feedback that is overly positive or not fully honest.’ You equally want to avoid judgemental feedback. Both affect your relationship with the writer. Either the recurring issue will expose your dishonesty down the track or you’ll destroy the writer’s confidence.
So how do you balance this? With objective feedback, for example: ‘Please replace all references to “The Department” with “we”. Our style guide tells us to use more pronouns in our writing because it engages readers and makes us seem more approachable, which is one of our brand pillars.’
Get help from the experts
Want extra advice on objective, specific and actionable feedback? Our free guide for reviewers covers these tips (and 4 others) in more detail.
For hands-on training, sign up for our Masterclass in Reviewing. It presents a systematic approach for reviewing a range of workplace documents and giving constructive feedback objectively.
What people say about the masterclass:
‘The tools are fantastic and have changed the way I approach editing and feedback.’
‘It helped me realise that despite my best intentions, I’m not giving writers a chance to grow their own skills.’